The latest book reviews in one place

10 Minutes and 38 Seconds in This Strange World Reviews

10 Minutes and 38 Seconds in This Strange World by Elif Shafak

10 Minutes 38 Seconds in this Strange World

Elif Shafak

3.73 out of 5

5 reviews

Imprint: Viking
Publisher: Penguin Books Ltd
Publication date: 6 Jun 2019
ISBN: 9780241293867
3 stars out of 5
Johanna Thomas-Corr
16 Jun 2019

"sensual but frustrating"

It’s a novel with a powerful premise, good intentions and an ingenious framing device. What’s more, Shafak is an inspiration to writers across the globe: a passionate feminist and champion of free speech who writes about political and sexual taboos... What a shame, then, that 10 Minutes 38 Seconds in This Strange Land is so flat and flavourless... The second half shifts focus to Leila’s “water family” – the outcasts who provide a safety net when her blood relatives desert her... This group of oddballs are known as “the five”, which makes them sound like a squad from a Marvel franchise. I don’t think that’s accidental – there’s something a little gimmicky and schematic about the whole setup. What begins as an incisive investigation into violence against women becomes both preachy and hammy as the friends go to dig up her grave and the action descends into farce... Where Shafak does excel is in conjuring Istanbul, a “struggling, competing, clashing” place she can no longer visit. In many ways, the book is a love letter to the city and its most stirring passages bring alive its tensions.

Reviews

4 stars out of 5
Mirza Waheed
12 Jun 2019

"a profound and unflinching look at sexual violence"

[It's] an extraordinary tale of a brutalised, broken but profoundly courageous woman who retains her humanity despite a world bent on crushing her at every turn. We see beautifully rendered, tender vignettes of her early lifeFor more than half the book... [T]he reader is guided by Leila’s vibrant but soon to be extinguished memory, each reminiscence sparked by a smell or taste. It’s a terrific device, taking us from the rubbish bin to a day in her childhood when she is banned by her pious father from playing with a hula hoop... Shafak takes a piercing, unflinching look at the trauma women’s minds and bodies are subjected to in a social system defined by patriarchal codes. It’s a brutal book, bleak and relentless in its portrayal of violence, heartbreak and grief, but ultimately life-affirming. Here, as in Shafak’s previous work, we find the good old-fashioned art of intricate storytelling, something I miss sometimes in modern fiction.

3 stars out of 5
Leaf Arbuthnot
9 Jun 2019

"A powerful novel from a writer under fire from the Turkish authorities"

[Shafak] is drawn to people at the margins and writes with immense compassion about those too damaged, defiant or different to fit in... The novel is no masterpiece — its prose can feel functional and is sometimes too emphatic — but the story Shafak weaves is deeply moving. And it can often be surprisingly upbeat, as Leila, an outcast herself, assembles around her a merry band of misfits who love her better than her blood family ever could. The result is imaginative and admirably tight, a novel that paints a memorable and nuanced picture of life on the fringes of Turkish society.

4 stars out of 5
Melissa Katsoulis
7 Jun 2019

"teases beauty and humour from a grim tale"

The novels of the Turkish writer Elif Shafak are so beguiling that it’s easy to forget she is a serious activist and academic. Yet beneath the lush scene-setting and romantic storytelling, her bestselling tales about modern Turkey and Islam (The Bastard of IstanbulThe Forty Rules of Love) are strident calls to challenge fundamentalism and misogyny in the Middle East... There is so much beauty in this book: the value of the “chosen family” to marginalised individuals; Istanbul itself, that “liquid city”; the grace of a Muslim father who would never strike his daughter, however much he feared her choices. And there’s wisdom too, courtesy of Leila’s fabulous trans friend Nalan: “No one should try to philosophise on the nature of humanity until they have worked in a public toilet for a couple of weeks.” Thanks to Shafak, the voices of women like Nalan and Leila will no longer be silenced.

5 stars out of 5
Francesca Segal
24 May 2019

"a vibrant evocation of a hidden Istanbul in the middle of the 20th century"

Turkey’s most widely read female novelist, her latest work written in English, 10 Minutes and 38 Seconds in This Strange World, is everything we have come to expect from Shafak. Here is not only that exquisite compassion and trademark humanity but also a vibrant evocation of a hidden Istanbul in the middle of the 20th century; touching, idiosyncratic friendships and the complex inner lives of the female characters for which she has long been known... This is a novel that gives voice to the invisible, the untouchable, the abused and the damaged, weaving their painful songs into a thing of beauty.