12,169 book reviews and counting...

All Our Broken Idols Reviews

All Our Broken Idols by Paul M.M. Cooper

All Our Broken Idols

Paul M.M. Cooper

Score pending

2 reviews

Imprint: Bloomsbury Publishing PLC
Publisher: Bloomsbury Publishing PLC
Publication date: 28 May 2020
ISBN: 9781408879405
  • The TimesHistorical Fiction Book of the Month
5 stars out of 5
Antonia Senior
18 Jun 2020

"Cooper offers no trite conclusions, just a welcome thoughtfulness at a time of so much noise and fury over statues"

Dual timeline novels often fail: one strand is more interesting than the other, or the links between the two are contrived. Not here. Both stories are superbly told and share the same preoccupation — the coexistence of cruelty and creative beauty. Cooper offers no trite conclusions, just a welcome thoughtfulness at a time of so much noise and fury over statues. When Isis terrorists smash Assyrian statues, Katya weeps — and so did I.

Reviews

4 stars out of 5
31 May 2020

"Cooper’s trips to Iraq and his historical interests ... lend All Our Broken Idols authenticity"

Siblings Aurya and Sharo go on a voyage of discovery to Nineveh; 2,600 years later archaeologist Katya joins a dig in Mosul against the backdrop of Isis insurgence that can only end in trauma. Naturally, these stories intertwine – perhaps a little too obviously – but Cooper’s trips to Iraq and his historical interests (he hosts the excellent Fall of Civilisations podcast) lend All Our Broken Idols authenticity. The novel underlines the fact that people in Iraq have always suffered – but always fought, too, for their identity and culture; the greatest treasure of all.