10,402 book reviews and counting...

Fracture Reviews

Fracture by Andres Neuman


Andres Neuman

4.13 out of 5

4 reviews

Imprint: Granta Books
Publisher: Granta Books
Publication date: 11 Jun 2020
ISBN: 9781783785131

A sweeping novel written with intimacy and compassion, Fracture encompasses some of the most urgent political, social and environmental questions of contemporary life, about collective trauma, memory and love. Already a sensation in Spain, it is major work of imagination from the prize-winning and highly acclaimed Argentinian author.

3 stars out of 5
14 Jun 2020

"This is an ambitious, serious novel"

Watanabe is an outsider, obviously, in the West, but as a hibakusha he feels set apart in Japan. Can such fractures ever be put together? Glimmering in the background are references to kintsugi, the Japanese art of repairing broken pottery with a lacquer mixed with powdered gold to make the fracture itself a thing of beauty. This is an ambitious, serious novel, and although it is not always successful, it is often golden.


5 stars out of 5
9 Jun 2020

"Perceptively translated by Nick Caistor and Lorenza Garcia, Fracture is a novel for our times and astonishingly relevant"

Perceptively translated by Nick Caistor and Lorenza Garcia, Fracture is a novel for our times and astonishingly relevant. Radiation, like coronavirus, is an invisible killer. After Fukushima, the official communications about the catastrophe prove unreliable. As one character observes: “the politicians say one thing and then the exact opposite. They don’t want people to panic, only to be reasonably fearful. That’s impossible.” Neuman suggests “truth depends less on data than on underlying metaphors”, and that it lies somewhere in the cracks between real events and fictions.

4 stars out of 5
9 Jun 2020

"a portrait of a survivor through the eyes of past lovers"

If a Japanese disaster seems an unlikely topic for Neuman, he was struck, he has said, at how most human cultures “seem equally capable of both powerfully rebuilding and self-destructing”.

As news spreads about the reach of the disaster, Yoshie is amazed to read that “the previous day’s earthquake may have moved the whole country by a couple of meters, and shifted the earth’s axis by ten or fifteen centimetres. Nothing occurs in only one place, he reflects, everything occurs everywhere.” The global reverberations of catastrophe - from Alaska to Sumatra - feel all too pertinent amid our present pandemic. (In a prescient detail, after the earthquake, Yoshie finds the Tokyo supermarket shelves empty of toilet paper and diapers.)

5 stars out of 5
David Pilling
3 Jun 2020

"in this enjoyable and strangely tender book, Neuman asks us to look beyond the present"

We find ourselves immersed in a story about a man written by a man but narrated by four women, an act of ventriloquism mirrored by reading the book in its easy-flowing translation (by Nick Caistor and Lorenza Garcia) from Spanish. On his travels, Watanabe learns Spanish as well as French and English. That leaves him incomplete in any language, including Japanese, which shifts during his decades of absence.