6,713 book reviews and counting...

Homeland Reviews

Homeland by Fernando Aramburu, Alfred MacAdam

Homeland

Fernando Aramburu, Alfred MacAdam

Score pending

2 reviews

Imprint: Picador
Publisher: Pan Macmillan
Publication date: 14 May 2019
ISBN: 9781509858026

An epic and heartbreaking story of two best friends whose families are divided by the conflicting loyalties of terrorism.

2 stars out of 5
13 Aug 2019

"Forty years of the Basque conflict, simplified"

Some reviewers have noted that it’s not necessary to know anything about the Basque conflict to get a sense of it from this novel. Taken to its logical conclusion this is a dangerous proposition. I want the story of the Basque people told, and all sides of it. But there are better ways of telling it – and they are being told in better ways: see, for example, Katixa Agirre’s Atertu arte itxaron (2015; Wait until it clears) or Joseba Sarrionandia’s Lagun Izoztua (2001; My frozen friend), both of which are crying out for an English translation. And yet these stories are not being translated, let alone turned into a television series. Maybe we should ask ourselves why.

Reviews

4 stars out of 5
Johanna Thomas-Corr
12 May 2019

"Brutality, terrorism and division infuse a powerful saga"

Homeland is a brutal, austere novel, broad in psychological and moral scope, about the human toll of the long, dirty war between the Spanish state and the Basque pro-independence group Eta... Aramburu is a captivating writer despite his tics. Few books make me cry these days but by the final page I found my eyes prickling with tears. By examining his society in such close detail, Aramburu encourages us to reflect on the bitter divisions in our own world and the opportunities we have for reconciliation. The people we learn most about in Homeland are ourselves.