10,869 book reviews and counting...

Miss Austen Reviews

Miss Austen by Gill Hornby

Miss Austen

Gill Hornby

4.33 out of 5

4 reviews

Imprint: Century
Publisher: Cornerstone
Publication date: 23 Jan 2020
ISBN: 9781529123760

A wonderfully original, emotionally complex novel that delves into why Cassandra burned a treasure trove of letters written by her sister, Jane Austen - an act of destruction that has troubled academics for centuries.

4 stars out of 5
2 Feb 2020

"delightfully and ingeniously...a novel written from the point of view of the lesser-known Miss Austen"

The television rights to this novel were sold at birth. No surprise: the dialogue is ready to roll, there’s a treasure hunt, carriages and libraries, dogs and swishing canes, and even a girls’ hair-brushing scene. People are going to love it, but I wonder if any screen adaptation will be able to convey the hidden treasure within this thoughtful story: the powerful, barely expressed knowledge of each other’s characters that both the Misses Austen took to their graves.

Reviews

4 stars out of 5
Brian Martin
25 Jan 2020

"Gill Hornby weaves a magnificent work of the imagination"

Hornby’s portrayals of Cassandra and Jane are tantalising. The elder sister is seen to be an obsessed, manipulative old woman, though seemingly well-intentioned. Dinah thinks her meddlesome; but she is a figure to be pitied for her lot in life. Jane is clever, single-minded, perceptive and sharply intelligent, her talent arming her against a world dominated by men.

All devotees of Austen’s novels will want to join Hornby, and Cassandra, in this enjoyable act of piety to Jane.

5 stars out of 5
Stephanie Merritt
20 Jan 2020

"a novel of great kindness, often unexpectedly moving, with much to say about the status of “invisible” older women"

The great joy of Miss Austen is that the reader feels immersed in a world that is convincingly Jane’s from the first page. Austen’s style is superficially easy to pastiche, but deceptively hard to do well (as ITV’s recent tone-deaf Sanditon attests); many have tried, but few have managed anything approaching her lightness of touch and swift, caustic wit. It’s testament to Hornby’s skill, then, that I had to turn to the author’s note at the back to check how many of the letters included here were invented. It’s also extremely funny; figures in Jane’s life who might well have provided models for some of her more bumptious, self-important characters are fleshed out here with a comic relish that feels entirely Austenian. 

4 stars out of 5
18 Jan 2020

"The sister best known for burning Jane’s letters is brought to life"

Historical fiction is difficult. One phrase can catapult the reader back into the present. The writer must avoid pastiche at all costs. I balked at a couple of phrases — “it was her truth” and “his otherness” — but these are tiny aberrations in an otherwise fine novel. Hornby’s most effective feat is to tackle the problem of family memory — each one of us has our (often misguided) reading of family history. Familial relations are complicated, and fraught, subject to misinterpretations and misunderstandings. Motives are complex and layered.