6,815 book reviews and counting...

Novacene Reviews

Novacene by James Lovelock

Novacene

The Coming Age of Hyperintelligence

James Lovelock

3.58 out of 5

6 reviews

Imprint: Allen Lane
Publisher: Penguin Books Ltd
Publication date: 4 Jul 2019
ISBN: 9780241399361

James Lovelock, creator of the Gaia hypothesis and the greatest environmental thinker of our time, has produced an astounding new theory about future of life on Earth. He argues that the anthropocene - the age in which humans acquired planetary-scale technologies - is, after 300 years, coming to an end. A new age - the novacene - has already begun. New beings will emerge from existing artificial intelligence systems. They will think 10,000 times faster than we do and they will regard us as we now regard plants - as desperately slow acting and thinking creatures.

2 stars out of 5
Roger Lewis
16 Aug 2019

"Lovelock’s rambling, maundering book indeed reads like the jottings of a trendy vicar"

Nevertheless, all this hippyish stuff about Gaia – Lovelock’s theory that the Earth, its objects and inhabitants, its biochemical properties and swirling gases, is a single organism with interlocking parts in fundamental harmony – seems mumbo-jumbo to me, like that scene in Hair where everyone is invited up on stage to do a dance. Lovelock’s rambling, maundering book indeed reads like the jottings of a trendy vicar who, in his youth, wore sandals, plucked the guitar, went to India in a camper van, and talked with a dazed expression about flower-power and how, when a butterfly flaps its wings in Patagonia, the result is rain in Abergavenny. Everything connects, see.

Reviews

4 stars out of 5
16 Jul 2019

"The Gaia theorist sees at least one reason why superintelligent machines might want to keep humans around"

Indeed, he enjoys striking out at the many failings of human intelligence. Foremost among these, he counts our reluctance to embrace nuclear power in order to stop fossil-fuel-induced global warming (“auto-genocide”), followed by fashionable fantasies of fleeing to Mars. This might make him sound like a curmudgeon, but the book is too leavened with wit and optimism for that. Novacene is the collected wisdom of an elder of our tribe which more than repays the short time it takes to read.

4 stars out of 5
1 Jul 2019

" it is as important and accessible as anything he has written"

I should at this point declare an interest. I have known Lovelock for more than half my life, and nearly half of his, and have written a biography (now clearly in need of updating) covering a large part of his life. I come to praise Caesar, not to bury him. That said, if his latest book had contained the ramblings of a once great mind in its dotage, I would as a friend have ignored it. But because it is as important and accessible as anything he has written, if shorter than one might have hoped, I can recommend it with a clear conscience.

3 stars out of 5
James McConnachie
30 Jun 2019

"an optimistic outlook from an unusual mind"

But this is not meant to be a closely argued theory. It is meant to be, and feels like, the last thoughts of an unusual mind searching for a concluding message. It feels like a conversation with the kind of generous older person who believes the best legacy is to provoke interesting questions.

Lovelock on AI is rather like Lovelock on planetary ecosystems. The hypothesis might not be true. But it doesn’t half make you think.

4 stars out of 5
Steven Poole
28 Jun 2019

"the book is a bracing corrective to the crypto-Christian guilt and self-loathing of much traditional environmentalism"

The hard science behind such speculation is explained – with the help of an amanuensis, Bryan Appleyard – with beautiful clarity, and a characteristic mischievous wit. Lovelock is justifiably proud of his record as a successful scientific maverick, and he especially enjoys trolling the more misanthropic green thinkers who suppose that the proper response to climatic catastrophe is to dismantle industrial civilisation, rather than to intensify our engineering efforts in alternative energy sources and mitigation... As a whole, however, the book is a bracing corrective to the crypto-Christian guilt and self-loathing of much traditional environmentalism. “My last word on the Anthropocene,” Lovelock writes, “is a shout of joy, joy at the colossal expansion of our knowledge of the world and the cosmos that this age has produced.” 

5 stars out of 5
22 Jun 2019

"the book as a whole is captivating"

I have never read a jauntier book about artificial intelligence taking over the world. It’s as if the writers of The Matrix had spent the film diplomatically refusing to take sides in the fight between machine and man. “For a while at least, the new electronic life might prefer to collaborate with the organic life which has done... so much to keep the planet habitable,” Lovelock says. A few pages later: “Cyborg scientists may well exhibit collections of live humans. After all, people who live near London go to Kew Gardens to watch the plants.”... Somehow, though, this hardly matters — the book as a whole is captivating. As Lovelock talks us through the steps that will take robots from servant to master it all seems entirely plausible.