11,630 book reviews and counting...

The Bell in the Lake Reviews

The Bell in the Lake by Lars Mytting, Deborah Dawkin

The Bell in the Lake

Lars Mytting, Deborah Dawkin

3.91 out of 5

5 reviews

Imprint: MacLehose Press
Publisher: Quercus Publishing
Publication date: 19 Mar 2020
ISBN: 9780857059376

The first novel in a thrilling Norwegian historical trilogy - by the author of The Sixteen Trees of the Somme

  • The TimesHistorical Fiction Book of the Month
4 stars out of 5
Antonia Senior
13 Mar 2020

"Myttlng uses the love story to explore the clash between tradition and modernity"

In this novel, the first in a trilogy, Mytting delves into his country’s past at a time when it is beginning to open up to the wider world. Astrid, a village girl, goes to work for the new pastor, the ambitious, young and worldly Kai Schweigaard. Schweigaard is horrified by the backward ways of the locals and keen to improve their lives, despite their determination to remain unimproved. His plans are thwarted by poverty, rural stubbornness and a melancholic acceptance that life is supposed to be miserable.


3 stars out of 5
29 May 2020

"Mytting presents a Norwegian kitsch of a historical nature"

This is Mytting’s fourth novel, and his second book to be translated into English (this time by Deborah Dawkin), following on from his surprise non-fiction bestseller Hel Ved (2011; Norwegian Wood, 2015), which rode the past decade’s wave of interest in Nordic and Scandinavian culture as natural, tolerant and hygge. That interest from without was always based on a reduction to a kind of kitsch: woollen jumpers, social democracy and cinnamon rolls. Now Mytting presents a Norwegian kitsch of a historical nature: a vision not just of a simpler past but one where Norway suffered under the yoke of the Danish Empire. Certainly it seems simpler than the country’s present, where a welfare state and ecological conscience are funded by the oil that is destroying the world for everyone else. And so, where we might have found a reckoning between Norway then and now, The Bell in the Lake prefers a version of historical authenticity no less legendary than a peasant tale, and no less artificial than a reconstructed church.

4 stars out of 5

"Set in 1880, this evocative novel about a Norwegian village on the brink of modernisation is the first in a trilogy drawing on local legends"

The Bell in the Lake is based on local myths and real people, and you can sense the hours spent by the author sleuthing through old church records for material. However, Mytting’s prose never collapses under the weight of his considerable research; he has seamlessly absorbed dialect words and phrases into his own vocabulary. Much of the local detail is inevitably lost in English, but translator Deborah Dawkin has gone to great lengths to create an equivalent of the rural vernacular, and the result adds wonderful texture to the translation. Although there is the occasional awkward phrase, The Bell in the Lake is a beautiful example of modern Norwegian folklore.

4 stars out of 5
Nick Rennison
29 Mar 2020

"Mytting’s cleverly crafted story heads inexorably towards a moving conclusion"

The Bell in the Lake (MacLehose £16.99, translated by Deborah Dawkin) is set in a remote Norwegian village in 1880. A young pastor is intent on tearing down a medieval wooden church and building a new one, so an architecture student is dispatched from Dresden to oversee its demolition and transportation to Germany for reconstruction. Both men are drawn to the free-spirited Astrid Hekne, a farmer’s daughter with ambitions to escape her life’s limitations. In their triangular relationship lie the roots of an unfolding tragedy. 

4 stars out of 5
20 Mar 2020

"a fireside read, with splinters"

Much like Marcel Pagnol did in his Provençal novels, Mytting shows how landscape and climate can define a character. He also stresses the currency of myths in a rural environment, how they provide a buffer to the elements. He delivers village wisdom — “You knew something was good, when the complaints stopped” — and jagged realism. It is a fireside read with splinters.