7,772 book reviews and counting...

The Great Pretender Reviews

The Great Pretender by Susannah Cahalan

The Great Pretender

The Undercover Mission That Changed Our Understanding of Madness

Susannah Cahalan

3.44 out of 5

4 reviews

Imprint: Grand Central Publishing
Publisher: Little, Brown & Company
Publication date: 5 Nov 2019
ISBN: 9781538715284

From "one of America's most courageous young journalists" (NPR) comes a propulsive narrative history investigating the 50-year-old mystery behind a dramatic experiment that changed the course of modern medicine.

3 stars out of 5
Bryan Appleyard
12 Jan 2020

"A fascinating piece of detection into what may be one of psychiatry’s worst hoaxes"

This book, choppily organised but passionate, is a warning against easy answers. The truth is we are strangers to each other. Sanity and love are the abilities we need to live with this. Insanity is, in these terms, easily understandable but hard to cure, perhaps because, even in its worst excesses, it is ever present as a possibility in our sane selves.

Reviews

4 stars out of 5
David Aaronovitch
11 Jan 2020

"She writes it all very well too, with clarity, economy and style"

I wasn’t really prepared for the story Cahalan ends up telling. That she discovered the truth about Rosenhan is a testimony to her dogged research. That this truth was inconvenient for her own outlook on psychiatry is a compliment to her integrity. She writes it all very well too, with clarity, economy and style.

And the truth is that Rosenhan was a fraud. What Cahalan’s research showed was that there were probably only two “pseudopatients” (Rosenhan himself and one other), that the accounts of their hospitalisation were fabricated, and that in one case where a genuine pseudopatient had experiences that did not fit with Rosenhan’s thesis, he was then excluded from the study.

3 stars out of 5
Steven Poole
10 Jan 2020

"Brilliant detective work reveals that a famous study of psychiatric hospitals was mostly fiction, but what are the implications?"

By the end of the book, she has adopted a more optimistic view, looking forward to new brain-scanning technologies and genetic research that might enhance our understanding of what can go wrong within the brain, the most complex object in the known universe. She does also finally concede that modern psychiatry helps untold numbers of ordinary people: psychiatric drugs “help many people lead full and meaningful lives”, she writes. “It would be folly to discount their worth.” But by the time of this grudging admission, pages from the end, this book might have been happily seized on by cultists and fearmongers who want to dismiss the discipline as a conspiracy cooked up by Big Pharma and the authoritarian state. The truth is that psychiatry, along with medicine in general, remains a highly imperfect science – but the book’s polemical implication that it has not moved on much since 1973 has the potential to be truly harmful to anyone thinking about seeking help now.

4 stars out of 5
Tim Adams
6 Jan 2020

"This inquiry into a 1970s experiment that shook the world of psychiatry makes for a compelling read"

Given her own experiences, and her twitchy investigative reporter’s nose, Cahalan was drawn to re-examine the case and its repercussions in the practice of psychiatry. The result of that inquiry is this compulsively readable book, in which she tries to track down the eight anonymous “pseudopatients” and examine the facts of their hospitalisation. Rosenhan died in 2012, the obituaries noting his famed experiment; with access to his original field notes, Cahalan was able to piece together the untold stories of his research and test them against reality... Cahalan, having unearthed these damning caveats, is not as damning as she might be. “Rosenhan’s paper,” she argues, “as exaggerated and even dishonest as it was, touched on truth as it danced around it.” That truth was the exposure of “the role of context in medicine”, the importance of diagnostic doubt as well as faith. Is it possible, as Chief Bromden observed in One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest, that Rosenhan’s findings represented “the truth even if it didn’t happen”? Cahalan is honest enough as a writer to leave that question hanging, having presented important and spirited cases both for the prosecution and the defence.