9,802 book reviews and counting...

The Journal I Did Not Keep Reviews

The Journal I Did Not Keep by Lore Segal

The Journal I Did Not Keep

New and Selected Writing

Lore Segal

Score pending

1 review

Imprint: Melville House Publishing
Publisher: Melville House Publishing
Publication date: 4 Jun 2019
ISBN: 9781612197470
3 stars out of 5
Rachel Cooke
7 Jul 2019

"This stop-start collection of stories and essays only offers hints of the American writer’s droll brilliance"

I understand why Melville House has put The Journal I Did Not Keeptogether. Her publisher rightly believes that Segal, who is 91 and still writes for five hours a day, should be vastly better known. In the US, where her first novel, Other People’s Houses (1964), was serialised in the New Yorker, and Shakespeare’s Kitchen (2007) was a finalist for the Pulitzer prize, she tends still to be thought of as a writer’s writer; in the UK, she is hardly read at all. But I’m not convinced that the way to bring her to new readers is by gathering together these extracts from her novels, some new and old stories, some scraps of memoir and a few essays. Whether by accident or design, the result is oddly repetitive, particularly in the sections of the book devoted to nonfiction.