10,402 book reviews and counting...

The Mystery of Charles Dickens Reviews

The Mystery of Charles Dickens by A. N. Wilson (Author)

The Mystery of Charles Dickens

A. N. Wilson (Author)

3.81 out of 5

8 reviews

Imprint: Atlantic Books
Publisher: Atlantic Books
Publication date: 4 Jun 2020
ISBN: 9781786497918

A brilliant and insightful celebration of the imaginative genius of Charles Dickens, published to commemorate the 150th anniversary of his death.

  • The TimesBook of the Week
4 stars out of 5
James Marriott
4 Jun 2020

"Wilson’s book is a brilliant denunciation of the sickness of Victorian England"

Wilson’s book is a brilliant denunciation of the sickness of Victorian England. He is especially vivid on the moral horror of a self-confident, capitalist society without a safety net for those at the bottom: the pregnant women dying on the doorsteps of workhouses; the native villages across the colonies torched by British soldiers; the prostitutes starving on the streets. The 19th century, Wilson writes, was “horrific in a way only the Victorians knew how to make worse”, with its “slums, treadmills, racist imperialism” as well as “their music halls, their usually unfunny humorous periodicals, their pantomimes and vaudevilles, their excruciating Gilbert and Sullivan . . .”

 

Reviews

3 stars out of 5
John Carey
7 Jun 2020

"clumsy attempts to match creator and creation contrast with Wilson’s more perceptive moments"

As a novelist Wilson must surely appreciate the subtlety of the relationship between an author and his characters. But in his treatment of Dickens it is crudely simplified. The monstrous dwarf Quilp, for example, who lusts after Little Nell in The Old Curiosity Shop, is “a demonic projection of Dickens himself”. No evidence is offered for this, except that “Quilp’s name is a shortening of Quill-pen, or the Writer”. Other Wilson breakthroughs are similarly presented as obvious. “Most of us realise”, for instance, when we first read King Lear, that it is like a pantomime, with Goneril and Regan as the Ugly Sisters.

4 stars out of 5
Estelle Birdy
7 Jun 2020

"Wilson focuses on the contradictory nature of Dickens’s character"

While the book’s subject matter is fascinating and the research impressive, there are technical flaws – unnecessary reiteration of established facts and Wilson’s over-fondness for certain words. Who knew that “pantomimic” could be used so often in one book? Faulty editorial decisions aside, this book will be an exhilarating read for both Dickens aficionados and those who have only a passing familiarity with his work. For the former, it’s a truly detailed examination of the author’s life, works and times. For the latter, the story of a strange and mysterious life led in the public eye may encourage the reading of Dickens’s work.

4 stars out of 5
6 Jun 2020

"this is a wonderfully fresh and vivid account"

But hats off – this is a wonderfully fresh and vivid account, fluently integrating life and work, teasingly constructed without being relentlessly chronological, and personally charged by an impassioned gratitude to Dickens that dates back to the imaginative solace his fiction offered when Wilson was a sensitive child incarcerated in a Dotheboys Hall prep school (chillingly described as “a concentration camp run by sexual perverts”).

4 stars out of 5

"Wilson has a fellow novelist’s understanding of what makes a piece of writing work on the page"

Why else would anyone still want to read him? A.N. Wilson’s new book, which shares its title with a one-man show acted by Simon Callow that was filmed in 2000, sets out to answer this question not in a traditional cradle-to-grave biography but by looking through a series of smaller historical keyholes in order to glimpse the larger picture. Some chapters deal with the writing of individual works, for example The Mystery of Edwin Drood, while others expand the focus to consider the private obsessions that Dickens needed to act out, such as the wildly successful public readings that he performed in the later part of his career.

4 stars out of 5

"A.N Wilson brilliantly probes and teases out in these seven 'mysteries' of Dickens"

As it happens, while writing this book, Wilson was looking from his own study directly through the window of the house in which Kate lived out her years of lonely exile. It’s highly evocative. Wilson is matchless in his atmospherics.

4 stars out of 5
John Mullan
3 Jun 2020

"...the novelist, hypocritical and self-deceiving as he might have been, has done him some matchless kindness"

If you are a Dickens aficionado, you will think that much of the book’s biographical narrative is well-known material, though here revisited in a sprightly manner. Yet its last, highly personal section suddenly shifts your sense of Wilson’s commitment to his subject. In his final chapter, he remembers first encountering episodes from Dickens at the age of eight or nine at his private school, which was “in effect a concentration camp run by sexual perverts”. The teacher who introduced him to Dickens was himself utterly sinister and Dickensian, the skill with which he impersonated Fagin and Squeers “all too convincing”. The shards of Dickens sustained his spirits among the privations and abuse visited on him by the paedophile headmaster and his monstrous wife, uninhibited sadists in Wilson’s vivid, detailed account. After this, nothing would convince him that Dickens should be condescended to as insufficiently “realistic”. And in returning him to the “abject terror and hopelessness” of childhood, but with that strange Dickensian stir of laughter (Fagin and Squeers, those comic turns), the novelist, hypocritical and self-deceiving as he might have been, has done him some matchless kindness.

4 stars out of 5
1 Jun 2020

" an enthralling, sometimes eccentric homage to a novelist whose works he has loved since childhood"

A N Wilson’s new book is an enthralling, sometimes eccentric homage to a novelist whose works he has loved since childhood. He tops and tails this very personal exploration of Dickens’s many selves, secrets and double lives with poignant recollections of his own lonely years at a bleak prep school, where he was beaten by a sadistic master. Reading his way through Dickens was then his comfort, an escape into a rich and cathartic comic universe. When Wilson writes of Dickens’s ‘profound understanding of the inner child’, it is an observation born out of the experiences of a real child.