14,424 book reviews and counting...

Unsettled Ground Reviews

Unsettled Ground by Claire Fuller

Unsettled Ground

Claire Fuller

4.33 out of 5

7 reviews

Imprint: Fig Tree
Publisher: Penguin Books Ltd
Publication date: 25 Mar 2021
ISBN: 9780241457443

'So sharply, so utterly brilliant that I found myself holding my breath while reading it, dazzled by Fuller's mastery and precision' LAUREN GROFF

5 stars out of 5
Hannah Beckerman
28 Mar 2021

"multilayered and emotionally astute"

Fifty-one-year-old twins Julius and Jeanie still live with their mother, Dot, in a ramshackle rural cottage. Their father died years earlier in a tractor accident for which the twins blame local landowner Spencer Rawson. When Dot dies, they begin to unravel their family history as they struggle to lead independent lives. Fuller explores the painful realities of poverty and social isolation with immense sensitivity in this multilayered and emotionally astute novel.

Reviews

4 stars out of 5
27 Mar 2021

"a propulsive portrait of shame and guilt"

Jeanie, the more engaging of the two, feels anger at how her illiteracy ices her out of ordinary life; she recalls how her mother implied "that an education for the kind of people they were – poor people, country people – would only steal her away from where she belonged – at home". The blows of destitution crescendo somewhat into melodrama in the final act – it’s the novel’s well-realised mood of shame and guilt that’s more propulsive and affecting. Unsettled Ground examines where the fault lines lie – at how a parent’s errors can reverberate through a life. 

5 stars out of 5
Sarra Manning
26 Mar 2021

"Both heartbreaking and heartwarming"

Jeanie and Julius Seeder are 51-year-old twins who live in extreme poverty in a fogottwn Wiltshire backwater and are sheltered from the real world by their mother, Dot. But when Dot dies, the twins are forced to confront not just the modern-day 21st centruy, but also the secrets that Dot had been keeping from them. This is an atmospheric thriller that's both heartbreaking and heartwarming. 

4 stars out of 5
Zoë Apostolides
19 Mar 2021

"Fuller displays a tenderness for her characters as well as highlighting the precariousness of even the most fervently believed truths"

Fuller is frank in her depictions of poverty, both of economy and compassion, and the shame just waiting to be felt in such a small community, where visits to a food bank could never go unnoticed. Broken and decrepit though the cottage may be, it’s where the twins were born and where Dot dies, unexpectedly, one morning of a stroke. “The worries of seventy years — the money, the infidelity, the small deceits — are cut away” in an instant, and the twins are left to fend for themselves.

4 stars out of 5
18 Mar 2021

"Fuller writes agonisingly well about poverty, and the cruelty of predatory villagers who smell fresh blood."

The theme of filial duty resurfaces in her new novel, which was deservedly longlisted for this year’s Women’s Prize for Fiction...

Jeanie, who can’t read or write, is a captivating heroine, almost Hardyesque in the depths of misery she’s put through.

Fuller writes agonisingly well about poverty, and the cruelty of predatory villagers who smell fresh blood.

4 stars out of 5
Melissa Katsoulis
13 Mar 2021

"a beautiful, powerful tale about real country life"

Fuller’s great skill is to create characters by stealth. They speak through their actions, rather than internal monologue: Jeanie pinning a drawing of her dog on the wall; Julius daring to offer himself to a woman; the two preparing their mother’s body for burial. The things they do subtly create who they are, and allow us to inhabit their situation ourselves. What would you do if somebody died at home and you had no money or phone but were handy with a spade?

Empathising with those who live under the radar is important work, and thanks to this memorable creation we might look more kindly on those less fortunate, and not turn away when some unwashed woman is being weird in a public place. This is a powerful, beautiful novel that shows us our land as it really is: a place of both shelter and cruelty, innocence and experience.

5 stars out of 5
Nina Pottell
1 Mar 2021

"I was fascinated and horrified"

I loved Fuller's last book, Bitter Orange, and was equally enthralled when reading this. Twins Jeanie and Julias have had a far from conventional upbringing. Aged 51, they're still living with their mother. When she dies, they are ill-equipped to cope with life. I was fascinated and horrified.